American Goshawk vs Broad-winged Hawk

The American Goshawk (Astur atricapillus) and Broad-winged Hawk (Buteo platypterus) differ significantly in structure and behavior. The American Goshawk is a larger, more powerful bird of prey with a distinctive long tail and short wings, adapted for maneuverability in dense forests. In contrast, the Broad-winged Hawk is more compact, with broader wings suited for soaring.

Look for the larger size and long tail of the American Goshawk, especially in forested areas. The bold white supercilium is a key feature. In contrast, the Broad-winged Hawk's compact shape and broad wings are adapted for soaring. Listen for the harsh call of the Goshawk versus the high-pitched whistle of the Broad-winged Hawk.

The American Goshawk is larger and more robust compared to the smaller, more compact Broad-winged Hawk.

American Goshawks have a distinctive gray plumage with a bold white supercilium, while Broad-winged Hawks have a more variable plumage, often with a reddish-brown chest and banded tail.

American Goshawks are aggressive hunters, often crashing through brush, while Broad-winged Hawks are more likely to be seen soaring in open skies during migration.

American Goshawks prefer mature forests with large trees, while Broad-winged Hawks are often found in mixed woodlands and are known for their migratory behavior.

American Goshawks have a distinctive, harsh call, whereas Broad-winged Hawks have a high-pitched whistle, often heard during migration.