Redwing vs American Robin

In short

The Redwing (Turdus iliacus) is distinguished by its red flanks and underwing coverts, and a prominent buffy-white supercilium. In contrast, the American Robin (Turdus migratorius) lacks these features and is more uniformly colored with a reddish-orange breast. Both species are thrushes, but their plumage and behavior provide clear distinctions.

Identification tips

1. Look for the red flanks and underwing coverts on the Redwing. 2. Note the buffy-white supercilium on the Redwing, absent in the American Robin. 3. Observe the habitat: Redwings are more likely in open woodlands, while American Robins are common in suburban areas. 4. Listen for vocal differences: American Robins have a more melodious song.

Size

The American Robin is generally larger than the Redwing, with a more robust build.

Plumage

Redwing has red flanks and underwing coverts, and a buffy-white supercilium. The American Robin has a reddish-orange breast and a more uniform gray-brown back without the distinct supercilium.

Behaviour

American Robins are often seen in suburban areas and are known for their ground foraging behavior, while Redwings are more likely to be found in open woodlands and are less associated with human habitation.

Habitat

Redwings are typically found in open woodlands and are more migratory, especially in Europe. American Robins are common in suburban parks and gardens across North America and can be resident or migratory depending on the region.

Voice

American Robins have a melodious song and a variety of calls, often heard in the early morning. Redwing calls are more high-pitched and less musical.